Their monotone acting skills just drive me crazy, and they are starring in a new movie together based on one of my favorite books - The Other Boleyn Girl. Scarlett in Match Point really made the movie great - because half the time it was like she was stumbling over her meant-to-be sexy come on lines. And Natalie..... other than The Professional, I just. can't. take. her.
Anyway, of the two, which one is the worst at acting?
can't choose. But i love how hollywood makes it seems like they are one of the best of our generation......it's just because the rest of young hollywood sucks even worst.Because it's all about being pretty and being famous. What happened to true talent. Okay i'll stop lol.
don't worry. we still know they're not good. NOT GOOOOOOOOOD. did you see mr. magorium's wonder emporium? ugh. so awful and terrible. natalie looks like a halfwit throughout.
Scarlett Johansson's not a good actress. She just play herself in all of her movies. Always the same expressions, that boring voice and face. I just can't stand it. And I find Natalie Portman good, though. Between Scarlett, Natalie and Keira I do prefer Natalie.
I don't prefer either of them particularly, at least they are better than some so called actresses I can think of (Jessica Alba, Jessca Simpson, Kirsten Dunst; at least in my opinion) Out of the two though, I have to say Natalie is the better..
Natalie is a good actress. Star wars was bad, is true, but natalie was not bad. The film destroyed my old star wars mith... sniff! 
none of them are bad. to me there really good..............love redcat!
I'm gonna have to go with Natalie Portman on this one, even though Scarlett is pretty bad herself. Natalie KILLED me in star wars. Ugh. You totally nailed it with the "monotone acting skills" line!